Bandwidth

Share

In 1890, William James devoted a chapter of his book The Principles of Psychology to attention. Attempting to describe it, he wrote, “Everyone knows what attention is. It is the taking possession by the mind, in clear and vivid form, of one out of what seem several simultaneously possible objects or trains of thought.”

James recognized different types of attention. For example, attention devoted to information coming in through our senses was different than attention required to think about that information. Attention to things that were of immediate interest was different than attention to things indirectly related to those interesting things. 

Perhaps most importantly, he distinguished between “passive” attention, which was automatic, and “active” attention, which involved effort.

136 years later, our definition of attention has changed very little from James’s version. Neuroscientists have been unable to come up with a more precise description because attention is not one thing. It is pretty much everything.

At every level of our mental and physical lives, attention is required. As our senses gather data, we decide what to notice and what to ignore. As our minds sort through data for relevant information, we decide what to remember and what to forget. Of the information we decide to keep, we decide what to think about and what to put on hold. Of the thoughts we sustain, we decide what to act upon and what to delay doing. Finally, we pay some attention to whatever we do or say.

At each level, as James observed, there are 2 modes of attention:

1) Autopilot, or hands-free

2) Manual, or hands-on

Absolutely everything our minds and bodies do can be done automatically, manually or both. 

Total attention capacity, including every level and both modes, is our bandwidth. We can imagine that, if this word existed in James’s time, he would have used it enthusiastically.  

Because it includes autopilot and manual attention, bandwidth is hard to measure. What it looks like from the outside can be very different from what is actually happening inside. 

As a general rule, we think and talk about the hands-on part of our attention, or the parts of it that require effort. The same is true for tests designed to measure attention. 

But bandwidth is the totality of attention, the parts we know about and the parts beneath the surface. And, for practical purposes, autopilot is our default attention setting.

From an evolutionary perspective, autopilot attention helped us survive. Every single one of our relatives, dating back to the dawn of humanity, had to sense, think, decide and take action effectively and consistently for long enough to make love, have babies and protect their wee ones until they could fend for themselves.  If they, and by extension we, had to put effort into remaining vigilant, figuring out what mattered and what didn’t, deciding on the best course of action and executing our plans at exactly the right times in precisely the right places, we would not be here to ponder the nature of attention. 

We exist because we do not have to try to pay attention. Our senses screen out the stuff that probably doesn’t matter. We think about what possibly matters. We do things that will potentially make a difference, and do not do things that are unlikely to pan out.

With practice, anything can be done on autopilot. We can get through large parts of our day without much effort. The more expertise we develop, the less active attention is required. Many motions through which we go would be disrupted by conscious, hands-on attention.

Still, many tasks can’t be done without putting effort into attention. Having a sense of our finances is very different from creating a spreadsheet with numbers such that we actually know our budget.

We have the ability, the freedom to toggle back and forth between autopilot and manual attention in any situation. We can check in on automated processes to make sure we’re on track, or check out of manual efforts once they’re going smoothly. Having a light touch, putting in just enough effort when and where it’s needed, is a balance both delicate and difficult to achieve. 

Bandwidth can go up or down when we are healthy or sick, rested or exhausted, optimistic or discouraged.

When we feel our bandwidth is maxed out, however, there are almost always semi-autonomous subroutines running in our minds, sucking up more than their share of attention before we can use it for whatever we’re trying to do.

Rearranging nonsense into something closer to sense, replaying past events or simulating future scenarios, grieving losses, dwelling on injustices or divining unspoken intentions are just some of the many background attention drains, all of which are set to autopilot. 

The most persistent, pernicious and parasitic of all such bandwidth-sucking entities, however, is attention devoted to maintaining and adding to the mental list of things we have deemed worthy of action, but have not yet done. 

These actions-in-waiting demand our attention because they have been tentatively approved, held in captivity and led to believe their performance is imminent. Unwilling to dismiss them, we create a special branch within our hands-off bandwidth where the Undone puts down roots. As its ranks multiply, more space and resources are allocated - automatically. 

Our bandwidth is broad. We are blessed with the ability to use attention with and without effort. When it seems we have reached our limit, we look for ways to economize, which requires effort we would rather not spare.

Strength is necessary to lift the rock under which the Undone dwells, but it takes courage to see what is really there. 

If we can lift and look, we will find a whole bunch of bandwidth. The tricky part is cutting off life support to the thing that is sucking it up.