GIGO
The signal-to-noise ratio, or SNR, was first described in 1948 by Claude Shannon, a communications engineer working for Bell Labs. The higher the SNR, he argued, the more information could be transmitted reliably. As it turns out, he was right.
Although Shannon was concerned with radio waves and land lines, SNR has been used to describe the quality and quantity of information transferred, processed or communicated in any way, shape or form.
We have access to a ridiculous amount of information. About 30 years ago, the internet became searchable by anyone with access to a computer, and cell phones were used by professionals and business people . By the year 2000, 50% adults owned a cell phone. The first iPhone was released in 2007.
Today, we all have the ability to know what is happening anywhere in the world, instantly. An iPhone 18 pro contains more memory than 94,000 original Apple Macintosh computers, and is capable of processing information millions of times faster. 4K video processing, speech and facial recognition, GPS and AI integration were the stuff of science fiction when the first Macs were sold in 1984. As a sidenote, Macs could not be used to make a phone call.
By definition, information is anything that reduces uncertainty.
If that seems vague, consider this: We are bombarded with data all day, every day, but only a fraction of that is information. Most data does not budge the needle on our uncertainty gauge.
The number 10 is data. The same number preceded by the words “It is,” and followed by “degrees outside,” is information.
Taking it one step further, only a fraction of data that qualifies as information is relevant. The statement “It is 10 degrees outside,” is relevant if spoken by someone entering the door through which we are about to exit. The same words coming through the speaker of a stranger’s phone in an airport have no obvious relevance. The stranger could be coming or going, and the voice could be in Minneapolis or Dallas. It’s always 10 degrees somewhere.
Not all data is information, and not all information is relevant.
Anything relevant is a signal. Everything else is noise.
Neuroscientists have applied SNR to brain activity. Within our minds, organized patterns of nerve activation are considered signals, while random, diffuse activity is called noise.
If there was a quick scan that could give each of us a personal “brain SNR” number, which there is not, it wouldn’t improve our quality of life. Knowing the ways in which signals and noise can either help or hurt the Undone, however, might be useful.
Our minds are making decisions continuously, with and without our awareness. We decide where to direct our attention, what to ignore, what to think about, what to do, and what to avoid doing. All of these decisions are based on the information available to us at the moment each choice is made.
Signals and noise are everywhere. They are all around us, in our thoughts and our actions. They provide feedback through the consequences of what we say and do.
Our minds, however, are not radio or cellular receivers. We have senses to gather data from the world around us, and unlike radios, cell phones and modems, our signal and noise criteria are personal, changing from one moment to the next. Static and dropped calls are always noise, and words clearly heard always contain signals. But a loud bang could be a car backfiring or a gunshot. They may sound the same, but only one is relevant.
We encounter SNR on 3 levels every day.
The first is input. Our attention is directed toward different sources, collecting data and filtering out completely useless information through sensory gating, our front line of defense. In other words, we notice or ignore.
The second level is processing. Our minds sort through data, distilling information to reveal the relevance within. We are very good at finding patterns amid chaos, coming up with ideas and solving problems. To maintain clarity of thought, we do our best to eject useless data and, if possible, to forget about it.
The third level is output. We decide what to do and say, what to avoid doing and saying, and manifest our decisions by taking action or holding back.
Ideally, we are searching for signals amid the noise at every level. We ignore the irrelevant, think about what is relevant, and act on ideas that seem worthwhile. The better we do these things, the smoother our lives flow.
The Undone takes notice when we focus on noise and miss signals. It salivates when we ruminate on nonsense and hoard junk data in our memory banks. And it feasts when we are paralyzed by ambivalence or act out of desperation.
We can leverage our awareness of SNR at each level.
First, we consciously choose our sources of input. Trusted informants: Good. Doomscrolling: Bad.
Second, we keep and think about what is relevant to us, and are quick to dispose of what is not. Consideration: Good. Rumination: Bad.
Third, we act intentionally, logically, sequentially and with purpose. Doing the next right thing and going with the flow: Good. Analysis-paralysis and shots in the dark: Bad.
Back in the 1950s, people working on the first computers had their own vocabulary. One phrase was used so often it became an acronym: “GIGO.”
The idea behind it was simple. If the information entered into a perfectly functioning computer was incorrect, it would come up with the wrong answer. Garbage in, garbage out.
Because our brains are more flexible than computers, we have the capacity to recycle a lot of garbage, converting into something useful. There is a limit, however, to the quantity of crap we can handle.
There are no definite high or low SNR environments. Noise can make signals more obvious, and too many signals can be overwhelming. We each have our own ideal SNR, and the right balance is situation-dependent.
The more accurate and relevant our information, the better our choices and actions will be. If all we collect is garbage, our attention, thoughts and decisions will be as noisy and disorganized as the data driving them.